By CostcoFan | Updated August 2026
Top pick: Kirkland Signature Organic Maple Syrup, 33.8 oz · Item #679131 · $12.99 (10/10)
We go through a lot of Costco maple syrup in this house — it’s on the pancakes, in the baking, in marinades and dressings, and sometimes on my yogurt at night. Over the years I’ve tried the pure organic staple, a premium vanilla-infused bottle, and the big cheap table-syrup 2-pack, so this is my honest, scored review of all three Costco carries. Each gets a score out of 10 based on quality, taste, and value. I’ll keep adding to this as Costco brings in more syrups — they rotate in specialty and holiday bottles (bourbon barrel-aged, etc.), and I’ll score those here as I try them.
This article contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, CostcoFan earns from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Quick Scores
| Syrup | Type | Price | Per oz | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kirkland Organic Maple | 100% pure organic maple | $12.99 / 33.8 oz | ~$0.38 | 10/10 |
| Crown Maple Vanilla-Infused | Premium organic, vanilla | $15.99 / 25 oz | ~$0.64 | 6/10 |
| Log Cabin Original (2-pack) | Table syrup (corn syrup) | $8.99 / 128 oz | ~$0.07 | 2/10 |
The short version: Kirkland Organic is the everyday winner and it’s not close. Crown Maple is a lovely premium treat but costs nearly double. Log Cabin isn’t really maple syrup at all — it earns its 2 purely on value for feeding a crowd.
First, a quick word on grades: you’ll see “Grade A” with a color — Golden, Amber, Dark, or Very Dark. It’s not a quality ranking; it’s about flavor intensity. Golden is the mildest, Amber (what the Kirkland is) is the classic balanced middle, and Dark/Very Dark are stronger and better for baking. All Grade A, all “real” — just pick the intensity you like.
1. Kirkland Signature Organic Maple Syrup (Item #679131) — 10/10
$12.99 · 33.8 oz · ~$0.38/oz · 100% pure organic maple, Grade A Amber
This is a staple in our household and it earns a perfect score. We use it for everything.
The reason we love it comes down to the ingredient list: one ingredient — pure organic maple syrup. That’s it. It’s genuinely nice to buy something where you can pronounce the entire label. It’s USDA Organic, 100% pure U.S. Grade A Amber, rich taste.
How we use it (basically everything):
- Baking — my wife makes healthy chocolate muffins and baked granola with it
- A sugar replacement — we’ll sub it in when we want a natural sweetener instead of table sugar
- Marinades & dressings — I use it for maple vinaigrettes and chicken marinades when I want that maple-sweet flavor
- Pancakes — our kiddo loves it on our gluten-free pancakes
- On yogurt — sometimes I use it in place of honey on my nighttime Greek yogurt bowl; it’s great with the cocoa nibs
Yes, it’s got a lot of sugar — it’s syrup, of course it does (24g per 2 tablespoons). But as sweeteners go, I think pure maple is a better choice than refined table sugar.
On value: the jug looks expensive at $12.99, but 33.8 oz is a lot of syrup, and a little goes a long way — it works out to about $0.38/oz. It’s the best price around, especially when it goes on sale. It has nearly 6,000 reviews on Costco.com at a 4.9 rating — one of those rare near-perfect products.
One honest note on texture: it’s a touch thinner than some syrups (including the Log Cabin below). But that’s because it’s pure — no thickeners, no fillers. I’ll take pure and slightly thinner every time.
Kirkland is Costco-exclusive, so there’s no legit Amazon link for it (anything listed is just resellers marking it up). If you don’t have a membership, the closest comparable pure organic maple is:
- 365 by Whole Foods Market, Organic Grade A Dark Maple Syrup, 32 Fl Oz on Amazon -> Tapped from certified organic maple trees in the northeastern united states and Canada, our syrup is pure, genuine and consistently delectable.
2. Crown Maple Madagascar Vanilla-Infused Organic (Item #1314399) — 6/10
$15.99 · 25 oz · ~$0.64/oz · Premium organic maple + vanilla (seen on sale as low as $4.97)
This one’s a genuine treat, and the flavor is great — it just loses points on value.
Crown Maple is estate-produced at an organic family farm in New York’s Hudson Valley. The vanilla-infused version has just two ingredients: organic 100% pure maple syrup and organic Madagascar vanilla bean. I love that ingredient list, and I loved the taste — the hint of vanilla is lovely and, to my surprise, not overpowering.
Where it shines: honestly, I liked it better on Greek yogurt than on pancakes. I sometimes stir vanilla into my yogurt anyway, so this let me get both the sweetness and the vanilla in one pour, right into the organic Greek yogurt. It’s also lovely on oatmeal or as a special-occasion pancake syrup. The glass bottle is genuinely nice-looking — it feels like a gift. My kid loved it too (though he loves anything vanilla and sweet, so that was a given).
Why it’s a 6 and not higher — two reasons:
- Value. At ~$0.64/oz it’s a little less than double the Kirkland. For an everyday syrup, that’s where you lose me.
- You’re locked into the vanilla. The flavor’s great, but if you don’t want vanilla in a given use, you’re stuck with it. I couldn’t use it for savory marinades or dressings — the vanilla didn’t suit my cooking there.
My honest take: this is a once-a-year, holiday-treat syrup. Bust it out for a nice weekend breakfast or the holidays. For everyday, I’m Kirkland Organic all day.
I tried the vanilla-infused; if you love the Crown quality but want a different flavor profile, these are the same brand’s other organic options:
- Crown Maple Organic Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup on Amazon -> Organic Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup, May Contain Trace Amounts of Alcohol
- Crown Maple Organic 100% Pure Amber Color Rich Taste Maple Syrup on Amazon -> Use as a topping for pancakes, waffles, French toast, and other breakfast items. Drizzle on yogurt, oatmeal, and ice cream. Mix in coffee, tea, hot chocolate, and cocktails. Use in baking for pastries, sticky buns, baked goods, and desserts
3. Log Cabin Original Syrup, 2-Pack (Item #843142) — 2/10
$8.99 · Two 64 oz jugs (128 oz total) · ~$0.07/oz · Table syrup
Let me be straight: this isn’t in the same stratosphere as real maple syrup. It isn’t really maple syrup at all.
Look at the ingredient list. The first ingredient is corn syrup, then water, then sugar, then a lineup of things that read like a science experiment. And a couple of label things worth pointing out honestly: the front says “no artificial flavors,” but the back lists “natural flavors.” The front says “no high fructose corn syrup,” but corn syrup is the first ingredient on the back. It’s not lying, exactly — but it’s the kind of front-label marketing that’s worth reading past. This is “table syrup,” not maple syrup.
I come at this from a more health-focused angle, which is why I’m hard on it. It tastes similar to maple syrup and it works like syrup — it’s actually a bit thicker than the pure organic, which some people prefer. There are traditionalists who genuinely love this stuff, and I won’t argue with them — it’s been around forever, and I remember liking it as a kid. When I’m out at a diner for breakfast, this is almost certainly what I’m eating, and honestly, ignorance is bliss in that moment.
So why does it score a 2 and not a 1? One reason: value, for one specific job. At ~$0.07/oz, the value is genuinely unbeatable. If you’re hosting a big pancake breakfast or feeding a lot of people, buying that much Kirkland Organic isn’t realistic — and this is where Log Cabin earns its keep. Two huge 64 oz jugs for $8.99 will feed a crowd.
But for our household? We’re not buying this again. For one family it’s just too much syrup — do you really need 128 ounces? — and when it’s just us, it’s Kirkland Organic only.
- Log Cabin Sugar Free Syrup, 24 Fl Oz on Amazon -> Log Cabin Sugar Free Syrup is a family tradition with a delicious taste and fewer calories Log Cabin original syrup. Full of rich, traditional maple syrup flavor, this Log Cabin syrup is a sweet, delicious sugar free option that’s ready to squeeze onto your favorite breakfast foods
Which Costco Syrup Should You Buy?
- For everyday / your household staple: Kirkland Organic (10/10). One ingredient, pure, best value, endlessly useful. This is the answer for almost everyone.
- For a special-occasion or holiday treat: Crown Maple Vanilla-Infused (6/10). Beautiful flavor, gift-worthy bottle — just pricey and vanilla-locked.
- For feeding a big crowd on a budget: Log Cabin 2-pack (2/10). It’s table syrup, not maple, but the value for a pancake breakfast is unbeatable.
For us, it’s Kirkland Organic all day — with the Crown coming out for the occasional fancy weekend.
Frequently Asked Questions
What maple syrup does Costco sell?
Costco carries Kirkland Signature Organic Maple Syrup (item 679131, $12.99 for 33.8 oz), the premium Crown Maple Madagascar Vanilla-Infused (item 1314399, ~$15.99 for 25 oz), and the Log Cabin Original table syrup 2-pack (item 843142, $8.99 for 128 oz). They also rotate in specialty and holiday syrups.
How much is Kirkland maple syrup?
$12.99 for a 33.8 oz jug (about $0.38/oz), and it goes on sale periodically. It’s 100% pure organic maple with a single ingredient — one of the best syrup values around.
Is Costco’s Kirkland maple syrup real maple syrup?
Yes — it’s 100% pure organic Grade A Amber maple syrup, single ingredient, USDA Organic. The Log Cabin, by contrast, is “table syrup” made primarily from corn syrup, not real maple.
What’s the difference between the maple syrup grades?
Grade isn’t quality — it’s flavor intensity and color. Golden is the mildest, Amber (the Kirkland) is the balanced classic, and Dark/Very Dark are stronger and good for baking. All are real Grade A maple.
Is Log Cabin syrup the same as maple syrup?
No. Log Cabin is “table syrup” — its first ingredient is corn syrup, not maple. It tastes maple-like and is much cheaper, but it isn’t pure maple syrup like the Kirkland or Crown Maple options.
Follow CostcoFan for more finds:
- TikTok: @realcostcofan
- Instagram: @realcostcofan
- Pinterest: @realcostcofan
- Facebook: facebook.com/costcofan
Related Posts:
